How To Choose the Right Type of Shovel
Editor: Greg Baka
Using the wrong tool for the job is the #1 biggest mistake people make when digging. It leads to unnecessary extra effort and dangerous back strain.
That’s why we want to make it easy for you to select the right shovel, for every project, every time.
The pictures and excerpts below are from a 1961 Popular Mechanics article titled The Right Shovel for the Job. The same advice that was good then is still good today. Shovels have not changed much, except for the switch to stronger handles. You can see the full article here (scroll the archive down to page 138)




"The long handle is best for stand-up digging or scooping as it saves you from stooping....The shorter D-handle is better where you
need to toss loads with good accuracy....The crosspiece in the D grip gives you something to push against during the start of the throw,
and something to haul back against when you 'shoot' the load....A long, straight handle provides you more reach for stand-up shoveling
without stooping, and for getting down into pits or trenches....After the hole is deep enough to stand in, switch to the shorter
D-handle shovel for good leverage and control."
Round or square point spade?
"A round-pointed shovel pierces the ground more easily, and is best for general digging, especially in rocky or hard soils. A square-edged
spade will sever roots that can slip past a round shovel blade, and so is good for transplanting trees. Spade also cuts a square-sided trench,
as needed for footings."
Note: Scoop shovels all have straight flat edges for scraping up material.



Lift: What it is. Why it matters.
A shovel's lift is the angle that it makes with the blade. The higher the lift, the greater the angle....For digging,
you want low lift so you can push the blade straight down into the earth, and still grip the handle comfortably. A high-lift
handle would force you to lean way too far forward, throw you off balance, and tire you out faster....For shoveling,
such as scooping and spreading soil, sand, or gravel, you want a high-lift handle so you can slide or scrape the blade flat
along the ground without stooping over much."
How to determine lift.
"Check for lift by measuring the distance from the tip of a long handle to the floor, with blade held flat against the floor.
It should be at least 32 inches for a good high-lift shovel, no more than 22 inches for a low-lift spade."
(Note: A combination shovel, what we call a
Digging Shovel,
will be in the middle of this range.)
Click to see more Shoveling articles or here for our full list of Digging and Trenching articles.
ARTICLES ABOUT DIGGING AND TRENCHING