Push Seeder or a Jab Planter?
How to choose the best type for your garden.
We offer two types of seeders and planters for gardens and small farms. The Hoss push seeders have wheels and are rolled down the garden row. While the jab planter is a tall device that you move to each planting spot.
Garden Seeder or Push Planter?
How to choose the best one for you...
You just need to answer these 2 questions:
1. Do you have sandy soil, or does it get fluffy after rototilling?
- If yes, then you must use the "Garden Seeder" model.
2. Did you answer No to #1, AND want to also weed or cultivate with your equipment?
- If yes, then select one of the "Push Planter" models.
Pros and Cons of the
"Garden Seeder" vs "Push Planter"
The section below will list the benefits and limitations of each model. It will compare factors like cost, soil preparation, other uses, and accessories. Do note that both models share the same seed hopper and seed plates, so seed handling and metering ability is equal for both models.
Garden Seeder details
● Can handle all soils, but needs a loose well-prepared seed bed.
● Always ready to use, not need to bolt anything on.
● The optional Row Marker is longer on this model.(36")
● Has a lower base cost than the Push Planter packages.
● Must have a well-prepared seed bed - no crusted soils.
● Only a seeder - no way to add weeding ability.
Push Planter details
● Good for normal soils - and can even handle lightly crusted soil.
● Can also weed, cultivate, or plow - depending on your package.
● Useful all season long, not just at seeding time.
● Does NOT work well in sandy soil, or those that get fluffy when rototilled.
● Has a higher base cost. (unless you just need the Seeder Attachment portion)
● The optional Row Marker is only 18" long.
How does your Hoss seeder/planter compare with other brands?
Very well, thankfully. The two other common push seeder brands are the Earthway and the Jang. See detailed comparison
All three do a good job with the big seeds (corn, peas, beans), but the Hoss and Jang are much better at small seeds.
Sandy soils make it tough to get traction, so a large diameter drive wheel is needed to compensate, and the Hoss Garden Seeder has the largest. Hard or crusty soils are another common challenge for the lighter-built Earthway and Jang, but the Hoss Push Planter powers through those soils because is built strong enough to handle plowing and weeding attachments.
Lastly there is cost: the Earthway is the cheapest, the Hoss is in the middle, and the Jang is the highest cost. Click here to read our customer's Reviews of the Hoss seeders and planters
Also see all our Seeding and Planting Articles